Murder Mystery Dinner Theatre

“Trial by Murder” | January 30, 2021 | 6:00pm – 8:00pm

Events & Holidays
Dietary considerations MUST be made at time of reservations.


THEME:  On November 4, 1933, the Pittsburgh & Ohio No. 1215 derailed after crossing the Bellaire Bridge, which spans the Ohio River at Benwood, West Virginia. A total of 72 individuals lost their lives in the derailment, and J.P . Morgenstern, President of the Pittsburgh & Ohio Railroad, is being charged with gross negligence in the maintenance of his locomotives. Federal prosecutors have indicted Morgenstern for manslaughter, and now he is on trial.

Reservations and Cancellation Policies

Reservations required.  Reservations must be cancelled at least 24 hours before the time of the activity. Guests will be charged the full cost of the activity if cancellation occurs within 24 hours of the start of the activity.


$79* per person
* Gratuity, tax and Historic Preservation Fund are additional.


Colonial Hall

Dress Code

Resort attire is required (collared sport shirts, sweaters, jackets, dress slacks and walking shorts). This event will enjoy an upscale and inviting environment. If denim is your attire preference, well-kept denim in a dark shade is ours. Men’s hats and baseball caps are not permitted.


Event is open to both Registered Overnight Guests and Day Guests.